Three cheers for Tony Lake in the FT

The Financial Times ran an interview with Tony Lake, Executive Director of UNICEF on 19th May: How Aid Got Smarter. Three cheers for three good comments:

“Often aid does work, he says. More children are getting vaccines and clean water. Aids, malaria and measles are finally in retreat. Life expectancy is soaring. But, he adds, “Of course aid often fails.” Then the question becomes: which aid works?”

First hurrah! Not all aid works; so we should measure & manage performance better. I’d just extend the question to: which aid works in which circumstances? We know blueprint approaches don’t work. So we need to consider local politics, causality and the view from the bottom up. More focus on management and participation, less on randomised control trials.

 “All those who work in the international community on development tend to overstate the impact of what we’re doing. What’s far more important is the performance of governments.”

Hurrah again! Get this straight, and we can focus on measuring the right thing, which is: how much value are we adding – not did we solve all the problems of poverty.

Finally: “You won’t see those dead or dying children in Unicef’s campaigns.” And that gets my third cheer. Let’s hope it stays true, unlike Save the Children’s shocking new poster campaign in the UK.

It’s great to see more open debate about improving how aid agencies measure and report their performance.

4 Responses

  1. Hi Alex

    I agree – great piece in the FT. I searched online for the Save campaign following your post, and I too found it upsetting. I would be interested to know if any discussions took place internally about the extent to which the use of these pictures met the guidelines of the CONCORD Code of Conduct on the Use of Images and Messages. This stipulates that images should not sensationalise, and that the highest standards should be met in accordance with children’s rights as laid out in the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

    http://www.concordeurope.org/Files/media/0_internetdocumentsENG/5_Press/13-EN.-For-approval—Code-of-Conduct-on-images–messages.pdf

    I am due to start a research study on the regulation of NGO advocacy in the autumn – a sphere where there is much less oversight than exists for humanitarian aid. Whether formal regulation would be appropriate or desirable is open to question – but at least initiatives like CORCORD can provide the NGO community with more frequent and meaningful opportunities to debate the ethics of such issues. I would be interested to hear your thoughts.

    Regards

    Angela Crack

  2. Quick update. Apparently Save are unconvinced by my comment about their campaign. Here’s the poster I saw on my way to work today, captioned “Six minutes. That’s how often a baby like Nirob dies” above a photo of a small, screaming baby from Bangladesh:

    And here’s Principle 10 of the Red Cross Code of Conduct, which Save has signed up to:

    “In our information, publicity and advertising activities,we shall
    recognise disaster victims as dignified humans, not hopeless objects.
    Respect for the disaster victim as an equal partner in action should never be lost. In our public information we shall portray an objective image of the disaster situation where the capacities and aspirations of disaster victims are highlighted, and not just their vulnerabilities and fears.”

    You decide if the photo meets the code! (And this isn’t even fundraising for a humanitarian disaster …)

  3. Hi Alex

    The picture I saw online was the one of the seemingly dead children on the ground. That’s even worse.
    http://www.savethechildren.in/nochildborntodie/home.php

    Angela

  4. […] to the FT include “3 cheers for Tony Lake,” a small Twitter storm and “The long and winding road to evidence-based […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: